Sign up for Text Messaging - Receive free cookies!

696 Ridge Road, Webster, New York 14580

(585) 376-0763

(585) 376-0763

  • Home
  • Order
    • Online Store
    • Order Delivery
  • Cookies / Cupcakes
    • Cookies / Bars
    • Cookie Cakes / Pizzas
    • Gluten Friendly
    • Alcohol-Infused Cupcakes
    • Cupcakes
    • Pies
    • Ice Cream
    • Truffles / Candies
    • Baskets by Simply Crated
  • More
    • Catering
    • Custom Stickers & Wrapped
    • Wholesale Cookies
    • Fundraising
  • Baker's Resources
    • Become a Home Baker
    • Order Frosting Sheets
    • Wholesale Supplies
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Order
      • Online Store
      • Order Delivery
    • Cookies / Cupcakes
      • Cookies / Bars
      • Cookie Cakes / Pizzas
      • Gluten Friendly
      • Alcohol-Infused Cupcakes
      • Cupcakes
      • Pies
      • Ice Cream
      • Truffles / Candies
      • Baskets by Simply Crated
    • More
      • Catering
      • Custom Stickers & Wrapped
      • Wholesale Cookies
      • Fundraising
    • Baker's Resources
      • Become a Home Baker
      • Order Frosting Sheets
      • Wholesale Supplies
    • Contact Us
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Orders
  • My Account

  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com

  • Orders
  • My Account

  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Order
  • Cookies / Cupcakes
  • More
  • Baker's Resources
  • Contact Us

Account

  • Orders
  • My Account

  • Sign out

  • Sign In
  • Orders
  • My Account
Kiss Me Cookie

your one-stop snack shop

your one-stop snack shopyour one-stop snack shop

Custom Designed Cookie Cakes

Additional Information

We design our cakes in three ways:

  1. Traditional frosting on a cookie cake
  2. Cookie Pizzas - Cookie cakes without frosting, but with a variety of candies and toppings
  3. Edible images and props


We want to work with you to design a cake you're proud to show off.  Below you'll find a number of pre-priced options for traditionally frosted cakes as well as our cookie pizzas.


If you're interested in a highly customizable edible image, we'd love to make your next masterpiece, sure to impress everyone at the party.  Contact us today to share your vision, and we'll work with you to get you a quote.


Please see galleries for all options below, and thank you for choosing Kiss Me Cookie!

Printed Cookie Cakes

Pokémon Cake with Bulbasaur toy

    Traditional Cookie Cakes


      12" Round Cookie Cakes

      Our cakes/pizzas are currently single sized as 12" rounds.  This is equivalent to 14 of our regular cookies, or approximately 35 ounces.

      These cut nicely into 8 larger pieces for hungry eaters, or 16 smaller pieces while still plenty for one person.

      Cookie Cakes

      Cookie Cakes

      Cookie cakes available in: Traditional Chocolate Chip, Golden Dough, Funfetti, and Butterfinger flavors (Imaged above)

      Simple Design

      24.99

      Includes your choice of writing, frosting color, as well as a border around the cake

      Decorated Design

      33.99

      Decorated to your specifications.  See photo gallery for examples of decorated cookie cakes.

      Printed Cookie Cake

      Contact us for quote

      Add any background image you can imagine and top with toys, figurines, etc.


      Please allow as much notice as possible if figurine/props will be required

      Gluten-Friendly

      Available in Traditional Chocolate Chip only. Made in a flour-containing kitchen

      Gluten-Friendly - Simple Design

      28.99

      Gluten-Friendly - Decorated

      37.99

      Layered Cookie Cakes

      A full-sized chocolate chip cookie cake, layered with options listed below

      Brookie

      37.99

      A Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake layered base, topped with a layer of our famous brownies and decorated with chocolate sprinkles.

      Layered Cookie Cake

      37.99

      A Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake layered base, topped with your choice of KMC cookie options - popular options include: Golden Dough (imaged), Funfetti, and Yin Yang.

      Cookie Pizzas

      House Specialty Cookie Pizzas

      A Cookie Pizza is a Cookie Cake without the frosting, but loaded with cake with various toppings instead. Pre-built cakes listed below, substitutions allowed. Cookie Pizzas available in: Traditional Chocolate Chip, Golden Dough, Funfetti, and Butterfinger flavors (Imaged above)

      S'mores

      24.99

      Topped with Graham Crackers, Marshmallows, Hershey's Milk Chocolate, Chocolate & Vanilla Drizzle

      Peanut Butter Lovers

      24.99

      Topped with Reese's Pieces, Peanut Butter Cup Pieces, Chocolate and Drizzle

      Candy

      24.99

      Topped with M&M's, Brownie Chunks, Marshmallows, Hershey's Milk Chocolate, Chocolate & Vanilla Drizzle

      Cookies & Cream

      24.99

      Topped with Oreo Bits, Marshmallows, Chocolate & Vanilla Drizzle

      Build Your Own

      Your pick of toppings

      Build Your Own Cookie Pizza

      26.99

       

      • M&M's
      • Hershey Bars
      • Marshmallows
      • Peanut Butter Cup Pieces
      • Graham Crackers
      • Oreo Bits
      • Butterfinger Pieces
      • Reese's Pieces
      • Chocolate Chips
      • Chocolate Drizzle
      • Vanilla Drizzle

      Gluten-Friendly

      Available in Traditional Chocolate Chip only. Made in a flour-containing kitchen

      Gluten-Friendly Cookie Pizza

      28.99

      Gluten-Friendly Build Your Own

      29.99

      All cookie cakes / pizzas must be ordered in advance!

      Catering

      Cookie Cake Displays

      Need cookie cakes for a larger party?  We have displays for rental to make a nice presentation at any event!

      Copyright © 2021 Kiss Me Cookie - All Rights Reserved.

      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions